"Be Home By Dinner" - How Much Has Parenting Changed?

Reported by: Evan Dawson
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 1/26 1:21 pm
The last thing my mother wanted to do was neglect her duties as a parent. She was attentive, hard-working, and loved her three boys dearly. And yet I wonder if she would be considered neglectful by today's standards.

See, we used to play all day, roaming far beyond the borders of our backyard. I grew up in a typical suburban neighborhood; tightly clustered houses bordered a forest that attracted our imaginations. During the summer we'd bang tennis balls off the roof of our house - that's how we determined a home run. When my mother grew tired of the sound of a ball smashing the siding, she'd tell us to do something else. We'd head down to the creek and search for crayfish, then head out to the woods to explore.

"Be home in time for dinner," Mom would tell us.

She loved us enough to set us free. We gained our independence as we invented games and searched for new adventures. It always seemed like we were worlds away from home, but in reality we were probably not too far. But no doubt we were out of Mom's sight, occasionally even crawling through the cornfield of the local farmer, who was rumored to keep a shotgun close by in case he saw a trespasser.

Keep in mind, there were no cell phones to keep us connected. Today, parents can text with their kids to get instant updates on whereabouts and activities. My mother did not have that option.

Don't get the wrong idea. My mother was no absentee parent. If we were late, we were in trouble. She wanted to know where we planned on going, and with whom. When we returned, she cheerfully but sternly wanted a full report on what we did. She wasn't afraid to ground us if we caused trouble.

But she trusted us to be responsible and she didn't flinch when we occasionally scraped a knee. That was part of life, part of finding ourselves.

In six weeks I'm due to become a dad for the first time. Parents tell me that things have changed, and you rarely see kids doing the Calvin-and-Hobbes thing, exploring and imagining and uncovering new ways to entertain themselves. With cell phone technology, you might expect parents to give their kids even more leeway, but the opposite seems to be happening. Some kids struggle to leave their parents long enough to get on a soccer field. Is it because we're in such a litigious society that every mishap becomes a lawsuit? Is it because we've convinced ourselves that becoming a great parent means being at the child's side at all times? Is it because the news media tends to over-report risks to children? (It's true; we're not always effective at contextualizing stories about abductions and the like.)

Or maybe it's not true. Maybe things haven't really changed, and kids really do have the chance to become independent and adventurous - within reason. Maybe I'm over-reacting.

But I don't think so. I wonder if I'll have the same confidence in my children as my mother had in me. I wonder if I'll ever say, "Just be home in time for dinner."

Evan Dawson/Anchor, Reporter
Share
4 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of 13WHAM-TV || Rochester

sethcburgess - 1/30/2012 7:41 PM
0 Votes
"Free Range Kids" -- I wonder if the idea of being more restrictive of children's activities is related mostly to the idea of security (ie. there are dangerous / sick people out there), or something else... ...because to me, today doesn't seem all that different, excepting for the "community that raises a child" being less active in the daily lives of it's individual members.

rbavery - 1/28/2012 12:21 PM
0 Votes
Read Lenore Skenazy's writings on free range kids. I believe letting kids explore is one of the best ways for kids to want to find out about their world. Yes, it's important to keeps tabs on the kids, it is not necessary to control everything. If you think you came out ok using your parents gradual increase in autonomy, continue it with your own child.

kdmask - 1/26/2012 7:46 AM
0 Votes
We lost that capacity long ago... I rarely if ever see kids outside their own yard. If a child is 'roaming' or even walking in a store alone under the teen age people panic. It's a sad thing. Fear overtook common sense sometime in the '80s. I remember my mom saying something like "when I was your age, I could kill and cook a chicken and now you're just out riding your bike all day, how will you ever make it, life is too modern"!

Myles - 1/26/2012 7:43 AM
0 Votes
Evan, your childhood sounds like my own! Looking for Crayfish, exploring the woods, etc. Mom didn't need to know exactly where we were, because it always seemed whenever we did anything wrong - even if we were out in the woods, Mom knew about it before we got home! We didn't need a cell phone, because I swear, we could hear Mom's whistle from one end of the street to the other. With my own daughter, we lived out in Bloomfield, so I often did the "be home by dinner" thing, but I do feel like I needed to know where she was at all times - not as many parents watching each other's kids.
13WHAM on Twitter
13WHAM on Twitter
    13WHAM News Headlines
    Laurie Fine To Sue ESPN
    Geneva, N.Y. - Attorneys representing Laurie Fine announced Wednesday that their client - the wife of former Syracuse University men's basketball assistant coach Bernie Fine will sue ESPN for libel. Video Video  |  Document Document: Laurie Fine's Lawsuit (290.4KB)
    5 minutes ago
    more 13WHAM news... 
    State News
    National News
    FBI confirms leak probe on al-Qaida plot
    FBI Director Robert Mueller says the bureau has launched an investigation into who leaked information about an al-Qaida plot to place an explosive device aboard a U.S.-bound airline flight.
    20 minutes ago
    more national news... 

    TheOffice

    Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
    Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.