Second Woman Accuses Pignato of Sexual Coercion

(Photo: Rochester Democrat and Chronicle)
(Photo: Rochester Democrat and Chronicle)
Reported by: Patrice Walsh
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 8/19/2009 3:38 pm
(Rochester, N.Y.) - New details have surfaced about a second woman's accusations that a suspended Greece Police officer coerced her to perform sexual favors.

Officer Gary Pignato already faces criminal charges for a similar incident involving another woman. Both cases allegedly happened four years ago.

In her statement to police, the woman claims Officer Gary Pignato followed her home in the summer of 2005 after seeing her drive by on Dewey Avenue.

Once in the parking lot of her apartment complex, the woman said Pignato got out of his squad car. She told police, "He started hitting on me, he asked me how's my sex life...he gave me his card with his name on it -- Gary Pignato.”

The woman says she never called Pignato but he showed up at her apartment a day or two later and allegedly watched her through a sliding glass door.

"I was smoking a bowl of marijuana, the next thing I know Officer Pignato comes inside my apartment. He said what I was doing wasn't good and we can make this go away. He made me a deal,” the woman told police. “I could have sex with him and that would take care of it.”

The woman also claims Pignato said she could lose her children if she didn't agree to perform sexual favors.

She agreed to go to his home in Greece the next day and saw Pignato through a window of his house, the woman told police. “I saw him snort a line of what I presume was cocaine...then we had sex.”

The woman said she came forward four years after the alleged incident after hearing reports about a similar case involving Pignato and another woman. "A few months ago I read about Gary Pignato getting in trouble for doing the same thing with another woman. And I said, ‘Oh my God I can't believe it.’!’”

Pignato faces felony charges of bribery, coercion and trespassing for allegedly entering the woman's home and official misconduct. 

He was arraigned Tuesday and released without bail. His trial on the initial charges begins June 1.

Pignato’s attorney Scott Green is troubled that the alleged behavior happened four years ago and the woman waited to come forward. He worries this could affect jury selection in the Pignato trial which is scheduled for June 1.
Share
11 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of 13WHAM-TV || Rochester

wolfy - 5/7/2009 9:28 PM
1 Vote
"My point is, a women would not voluntarily allow herself to be raped under the fear of some minor charge." Really? Is that a "law" of human nature? You know very little about human nature (that's for sure). Allowed to be raped?? I think you need to stop commenting. You are making an ass of yourself (on many levels). Nobody consents to rape. (BTW, I am a man). The "minor" charge of marijuana possession can damage a person's career opportunities...and do not get me started on our insane drug laws..which the law enforcement establishment financially benefits from - as they destroy civil liberties on a daily basis - all the while illicit drug use rates have not gone down one bit. The officer in question is a criminal for two key reasons: 1. He used his position to sexually assault women. 2. He took on a position where he could be an active supporter of our criminal drug laws. I am shocked that you have no clue when it comes to understanding that it is extremely difficult to get internal affairs to thoroughly investigate complaints.

whambam - 5/7/2009 12:32 PM
0 Votes
well wolfy you seem to have a huge chip on your shoulder. My point is, a women would not voluntarily allow herself to be raped under the fear of some minor charge. The punishment for drinking alcohol and smoking weed is far less then allowing this to happen to themselves. As far as your hatred towards the police, im not trying to defend pignato. My point is, these women allowed this to happen.

wolfy - 5/6/2009 10:47 PM
0 Votes
I have another nomination for idiotic forum comment of all time: "Id like for one women to admit on this site that they would have sex with some strange man if they were scared about getting into trouble for drinking or smoking weed." Well, corrupt officers can be quite convincing when they are skilled at threatening suspects into complying with their demands. Amd no, I have never been arrested or committed any crimes (I am sure the moronI am replying to is already thinking of writing: "Oh, you got a beef with officers because you are a criminal"). "This is sad but the truth is, probationers and parolees can get away with some crazy stuff before they get violated and go to jail." Umh, and officers of the law do get away with some "crazy" stuff (To name a few: lying, abuse of suspects, planting evidence on suspects..ect..ect).

whambam - 5/6/2009 10:35 PM
0 Votes
I believe he said these things to these women and he admits to having sex with them but i dont believe, even for a second, that these women were scared into having sex. They could have easily made a complaint against him before dropping their pants. Id like for one women to admit on this site that they would have sex with some strange man if they were scared about getting into trouble for drinking or smoking weed. This is sad but the truth is, probationers and parolees can get away with some crazy stuff before they get violated and go to jail.

whambam - 5/6/2009 10:26 PM
0 Votes
capriceclassic...that had to be the most insane, unfounded, idiotic, comment anyone has ever posted here.

CapriceClassic - 5/6/2009 6:46 PM
0 Votes
People in this neck of the woods are cowards and stupid. Only in Monroe County could some stupid idiotic mess like this go down.

CommonSence - 5/6/2009 6:36 PM
1 Vote
I wouldn't be so sure about that beetoka...I'm not at liberty to say anything, but there are more then just the two, they just won't come forawrd or won't testify. It's pretty sad this guy is only being charged by the two women.

beetoka - 5/6/2009 6:06 PM
0 Votes
this woman is full of crap. she is just jumping on the bandwagon

CommonSence - 5/6/2009 5:20 PM
0 Votes
This guy is a total scumbag and pvssy, does anyone else think he'll kill himself before he goes to prison? He couldn't handle prison life, he'll be the one preyed on there.

patticake - 5/6/2009 4:45 PM
0 Votes
sounds like he preyed on women with some sort of addiction (alcohol or drugs) and then took advantage of them. Shame on him that is wrong 100% and he deserves to be punished. But what the heck is a mom who is affraid to lose her kids doing with drugs in her house and smoking it so people outside can see?!?! How dense does one have to be!?!? And to honestly believe this could all go away for sex?!?! Maybe if you laid off of the drugs you might see clearly enough to know thats not how the law works, and had you made a phone call or two this would not have gone on and others would not have gone through it. Come on people - smoking pot is so high school - when are you people going to grow up and take responsibility for yourselves and your families?! you have kids, there will be plenty of time to be stupid after you have raised your kids. Shame on this woman for waiting four years, and only saying something because someone else is. And lets see she'll probably want some monetary compensation, gee i wonder where that money will go to!!!
Bookmark and Share

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.