Web Exclusive: Victim Comments on Pignato Sex Abuse Case

Reported by: Jane Flasch
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 8/19/2009 3:40 pm

Note: 13WHAM does not release the names of victims of sexual crimes.

(Rochester, N.Y.)  -- On Wednesday, Judge Alex Renzi sentenced former Greece Police officer Gary Pignato to two to six years in prison after he was convicted of coercing a woman into sex, accepting sex as a bribe, and official misconduct.

The day after, the victim in this case called it "a victory for justice," and celebrated by cutting the grass, pulling weeds, and doing other physical work in her yard.

"I just have to stay busy, it keeps my mind off the things I don’t want to think about,” she said.

Those "things" include the summer night Pignato responded to a domestic dispute at her home.

“It’s a nightmare that doesn’t go away,” she said while standing in the driveway of her home.  “You find yourself reliving the events over and over.” 

As she talks about it, her hands, shoulders--even her hair--tremble.  It is much the same reaction she had sitting in court on Wednesday watching the sentencing. 

"I had hoped and prayed for justice every night, but I never, never, thought I’d get it," she said Thursday. 

New York State allows victims to make an impact statement on the day of sentencing and she had planned to tell her story in court: how she no longer feels safe riding in an elevator alone with a man she doesn’t know; how seeing anyone in uniform fills her with fear. 

But, those words went unspoken in the courtroom. When asked if she was ready to speak, she shook her head.

"I felt the weight of the world on my shoulders," she said. "I remember testifying, his eyes bore right into me. I couldn’t do that again."

However, as is also his right, Pignato did address the court. He pleaded for leniency on behalf of his two daughters, ages 11 and 14. He said by losing his career, his source of income, and spending time in the county lock-up he had suffered enough.

"It reminded me of how he was that night," his victim said. "He was arrogant and cocky and not considering me or any of the other women. It made me sick and angry." 

Thirteen other women have filed "Jane Doe" briefs against former officer Gary Pignato.

Since it’s likely most of those cases will never go to trial, this victim--designated "Jane Doe 2"--said Thursday she was speaking out on their behalf.

She will also testify in another case against Pignato, after which she plans to leave the state. She’ll take her dignity with her, she said, along with a better life. 

She has entered rehabilitation to help with the drug and alcohol habits that led to the police call the night Pignato was on duty. 

She has been clean and sober for a year and plans to stay that way. 

“It’s hard to think of something good coming out of this, but I got my life back,” she said.

Share
17 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of 13WHAM-TV || Rochester

whati think - 7/11/2009 8:45 AM
0 Votes
he only cried because he got caught. he is sorry he got caught. not sorry for what he did to his victims. he's right where he belongs. i would really love to know how long he thought he was going to get away with it.

SeekingBalance - 7/10/2009 2:08 PM
0 Votes
Pignato cried in court. I wonder how he responded to the cries of his victims.

dragonlady - 7/10/2009 1:14 PM
1 Vote
hellogeorge Hows the air up there? Are you saying that because the victims weren't outstanding citizens they deserved to be to treated like that? He abused authority and NO ONE should have to be taken advantage of by authority or anyone else...if they don't do their job and protect you WHO do you trust? The victims are human beings and they deserve to be treated just like you or anyone else...their personal life is not in question here. You are judging them and they are the victims...what gives you the right to say they aren't girl scouts...does that matter?? Sounds like you need to get off your pedestal and learn that just because someone doesn't live up to your standards it doesn't mean they shouldn't be treated any less equal...HE is the one that committed the crime!

whati think - 7/10/2009 12:44 PM
0 Votes
hellogeorge- have you ever broken the law? I have. I have sped, driven when I probably could have gotten a DWI or DWAI. I think pretty much everyone has done something, no matter how big or how small. So is it OK if we are all violated by a police officer because we aren't girl scouts or boy scouts? Then that would make what Arthur Shawcross did OK, right? I hope that never happens to anyone you care about!

HolleyResident - 7/10/2009 12:14 PM
1 Vote
"A victory for Justice" ? He is doing 2-6 for something that will affect the victims a lifetime. I call that an insult. Granted, the victim may have been drunk but he should not have taken advantage of that moment. PIG-nato cried in court asking for leniency because of his daughters. He should've thought of his daughters before he unzipped his pants. Just another wasted day in court if you ask me.

HelloGeorge - 7/10/2009 11:33 AM
0 Votes
Piggy is pure scum, there is no question about it, but I can’t express too much sympathy for the victims, they weren’t exactly girl scouts. She will most likely get a nice settlement from the town, much more than she deserves. The town should pay for counseling and any other expenses related to this incident, but that’s about it.

dgw4381 - 7/10/2009 9:59 AM
1 Vote
I hope the victims of Gary Pignato get some professional help. They will all need it. It's tough to battle PTSD by yourself. Please, any victims of this scumbag, please seek the proper help to get you through these difficult times. You were violated. You didn't ask to be, he just took what he wanted. PIG!

PEMiller - 7/10/2009 8:18 AM
2 Votes
I can't believe he pleaded for leniency - he should have thought about his two daughters, his job and his income before he violated these women.

whati think - 7/9/2009 11:53 PM
3 Votes
no one has the right to violate someone because they have a criminal record. Especially a person who is sworn to serve and protect. "A loose woman about to sue the TOG" She would have nothing to say right now if Pignato didn't break the law and disregard the oath of a sworn police officer. So he is the criminal here, not her. And not the other women who have also made complaints and the ones who are still going to come forward. We haven't even scratched the surface here......

4everFord - 7/9/2009 10:24 PM
2 Votes
Sure Huntmeup...blame the victim and not the rapist wearing a cop's uniform.
Bookmark and Share

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.