13WHAM Weather Authority Alert: Freeze Warning expires at 7:00 AM on 5/25, issued at 3:22 PM Hunt, NY

Mom Of Marcus Whitman Student Defends Son After Bus Incident

Reported by: Alexis Arnold
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 6/24/2012 7:50 pm
Canandaigua, N.Y. - Johanna Dunkel says she wants to tell her side of the story.

Dunkel says two weeks ago her nine-year-old son came home crying because he says the bus driver lashed out at him.

Ontario County Sheriff’s deputies say 47-year-old Susan Mantz, a bus driver for the Marcus Whitman School District, was parked outside of the high school on June 8 when one of the students on the bus became disruptive.

To keep him quiet, Mantz allegedly put her hand over the student’s mouth.

Dunkel says the school allowed her to see the school bus video.

She describes to 13WHAM what she saw and she says it was much more than a bus driver putting their hands over her son's mouth.

“She pounced on him and placed her hands very hard over his mouth, the other hand behind his head and was leaning him back in his seat and was literally screaming at him for a good 10 to 15 seconds,” Dunkel said.

Dunkel says she could hear the bus driver telling her son that he needed to shut his mouth, sit still and that she was sick of him.

This news is coming out in light of the incident with a Greece school bus monitor.

Dunkel says she wants to clear up some misconceptions about her and her son.

She says she's seen hundreds of messages on Facebook of people comparing her son to the boys in the Greece incident.

Dunkel says that couldn't be farther from the truth.

“That situation, those children were out of line and were bullies and I believe they should be disciplined for that behavior,” Dunkel said. “In this case Susan Mantz was the bully and in this case my son was the victim.”

“My son is only a nine-year-old child and everyone's assuming he's, since it said in the article this was a high school run that he's some high school teenage bully who's out of control,” Dunkel said. “I've been a good mother and he's a wonderful child. He's very sweet and outgoing and caring.”

Dunkel says she wants that bus driver removed and shouldn’t be working with children.

13WHAM reached out to the Marcus Whitman School District.

They declined an interview but did tell us the bus driver is on paid leave.

 

 

Share
28 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of 13WHAM-TV || Rochester

nysnurse1 - 6/25/2012 1:55 PM
0 Votes
This mother needs to have taught her son how to behave when on the bus.the bus driver has many other things to worry about than your misbehaved son.you said he is sweet and smart,well mom not so sweet or smart to provoke a driver to shut him up.time outs dont always work.start teaching him respect and how to behave.dont give him your support to behave like that. and for the bus driver naughty naughty got to be a better way.

Agorath - 6/25/2012 8:48 AM
0 Votes
I would also like to hear what transpired prior to the Bus driver trying to quiet the Kid. Me thinks there is a big part of the story missing here...

Oldtimer - 6/25/2012 6:37 AM
0 Votes
How many times have you read "not my child,he is a sweet lovable boy" after a reported shooting? Child monsters are in the making to become adult monsters. If the parents were forced to do the punishments for their "sweet kids", it might have a positive effect.

rubymom - 6/24/2012 8:32 PM
0 Votes
I have been a bus driver for 12 years and we are taught from the very beginning of our training that you never put your hands on any child NO MATTER WHAT!!! you write the kid up or put them in the front seat, or here's an idea PUT CAMERA'S ON THE BUS

eatthebankers - 6/24/2012 3:07 PM
1 Vote
Instead of making excuses on why you didn't teach your child to do what an authority figure tells them, why don't you drive him to school? When our son acted up on the bus- he was banned for a month. We had to drive him and pick him up. It was inconvenient, and he got the message...Teach him RESPECT.I stand behind the driver 100%.

bdt4u - 6/24/2012 2:49 PM
1 Vote
Mommies and Daddies grow up and start remembering you have kids till its too late and they make the news stop covering up and become PARENTS

Santa - 6/24/2012 2:34 PM
0 Votes
Why is it that she (like most parents) thinks her child is an angel and his disruptive behavior should be handled with a stern "no no". Discipline starts at home and apparently there is little or none there. The poor driver was doing what the parents have failed to do and the parents are the only only ones in the wrong!

caponesgirl - 6/24/2012 11:49 AM
1 Vote
It is crazy how society is allowing children when I was a kid my momma would think of nothing to swatting me on the ass now we just let the kids now days we are raising a bunch of juvenile delinquents if her son was a angel would he be getting told to be quiet on the bus it wont be much longer and he could be like the kids in Greece schools kids who cant be controlled should have to be driven in to school by there parents and the parents should have to stay at the school with them maybe then parents would start disapline there children we have juvenile halls full of kids who were supposed to be angels according to there parents

KarmaJustice - 6/24/2012 11:44 AM
2 Votes
Funny how the mother didn't describe the situation BEFORE the bus driver put the clamp on her kid's mouth. Was he being loud? Obviously something was going on to have the driver react that way and I'm not buying the "He's only 9 years old" line either. Kids these days can act like little devils no matter what the age! Riding the bus is a privledge, NOT a right. Parents and kids need to understand this. A bus driver not only has to be mindful of their surroundings, traffic, other driver's and such, they have to also keep an eye on the passengers. Parents start teaching your kids how to behave on the bus.

BillL - 6/24/2012 11:39 AM
0 Votes
Just a little off point, the Karen Klein incident disgust me. However, I've heard similar stories from a Greece School Bus driver for a few years now. What I find interesting is why no one questioned why Mrs. Klein or the bus driver didn't report this incident. The answer, no one in authority cared until it went viral. Greece and most School Districts have a policy that: "The squeaky wheel gets the grease." There is no shortage of squeaky wheels with obnoxious kids in School Districts today. Some how today, in this Country, good behavior is punished and bad behavior gets rewarded.
National News

TheOffice

Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.