Should Pistol Permit Info Be Public?

Reported by: Sean Carroll
Set Text Size SmallSet Text Size MediumSet Text Size LargeSet Text Size X-Large
Share
Updated: 1/04 7:33 pm

Monroe County, N.Y. --- It’s become a statewide if not a national debate.  Should the names and addresses of people owning pistol permits be a matter of public record?

Currently in New York State that information is a public record.  But last month a Lower Hudson Valley newspaper, The Journal News, published that information in a mapping program online for permit owners living in Rockland and Westchester counties.

This week Putnam County leaders publicly denied the request by that newspaper.

"I'm going to take care of the people of Putnam County,” Putnam County Clerk Dennis Sant said at a press conference.  “That is what I'm going to do.”

For Ken Mathison of S.C.O.P.E. (the Shooter’s Committee On Public Education) that is a welcome response and one he and others have advocated on behalf of for many years.

"It's private information, it shouldn't be made public," Mathison argues.  "It's not only my safety but the safety of the rest of the public.  If you don't know who has the guns you're not going to take a big chance of breaking into somebody's house."

Others are also weighing when asked if pistol permit information should remain public.

"No, not at all,” Bill Clagg of Rochester said.  “It should be private it shouldn't be out there for anybody to access."

"I would agree with him, I don't think it's right,” John of Henrietta said.  “I don't own a gun myself but I don't think you should be publishing the names it's just not right."

"You think ones that are not registered are the ones being used for gang violence, homicides, stuff like that," Renise Ward of Henrietta said. 

"It wouldn't concern me," Ciara Cannon said of having that information made public.  "If you have kids a lot of people don't want guns in their house or nowhere near their kids because if that kid goes to that neighbors house and they know that they have a gun they're going to be like don't go there because they have a gun or make sure they have that gun in a safe spot."

Monroe County Clerk Cheryl Dinolfo issued this statement in response to our inquiry about whether or not she would release such info if it was requested by the public.  (*NOTE: Currently the Clerk’s website allows access to pistol permit holder’s name and address if one searches by a person’s name.)

"Should a request be made for a database list of all County and City pistol permit holders, I would invite the news reporter to sit down with me and have a discussion about the potential impact of publicizing this information through the electronic media.  I would hope that after a reasonable discussion about the fact that the requested information includes the names and addresses of law enforcement officials and victims of domestic violence, that the request would be withdrawn.  This request would effectively provide a map for criminals seeking to burglarize homes they know have or do not have a registered firearm. Judging by the public outcry in downstate counties, I think we can all agree that this is a topic that warrants a thorough discussion by our State Legislature.  Absent action by the State Legislature or the withdrawal of the request, I would continue to provide the legally required information that is currently available on our website and would not provide a comprehensive database of permit holders.”

Share
13WHAM News Headlines
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.